UMich Sentiment Catching Up with the (Good Economic) News?

From TradingEconomics on 10/25:

The University of Michigan consumer sentiment for the US was revised higher to 70.5 in October 2024 from a preliminary of 68.9, marking a third consecutive month of rises and reaching the highest level in six months. Both economic conditions (64.9 vs 62.7) and expectations (74.1 vs 72.9) were revised higher. This month’s increase was primarily due to modest improvements in buying conditions for durables, in part due to easing interest rates. The upcoming election looms large over consumer expectations. Overall, the share of consumers expecting a Harris presidency fell from 63% last month to 57%

This is a slightly different take than what the NYT had on this subject. Here’s a picture of the Michigan sentiment index, with the Cummings-Tedeschi adjustment to the preliminary series, and the implied adjustment to the final series.

Figure 1: UMich Consumer Sentiment (bold black, left scale), October preliminary (gray +), Consumer Sentiment adjusted per Cummings-Tedeschi (light blue, left scale), Cummings-Tedeschi adding in final vs preliminary gap (blue +), and Shapiro-Sudhof-Wilson Fed News Sentiment (scarlet, right scale), Source: University of Michigan, Cummings-Tedeschi, SF Fed

Taking the adjustment literally, this is the picture, compared to partisan group indicators (all unadjusted).

Figure 2: UMich Consumer Sentiment (bold black), for Democrats (light blue), for Independents (chartreuse), for Republicans (red), Cummings-Tedeschi overall sentiment adding in final vs preliminary gap (blue +). Source: University of Michigan, Cummings-Tedeschi, and author’s calculations. 

Finally, note that with the Cummings-Tedeschi adjustment, the Michigan indicator is more in line with the Conference Board and Gallup measures.

Figure 3: U.Michigan Sentiment adjusted to Cummings-Tedeschi April-October (bold black, left scale), Conference Board Confidence (teal, left scale), Gallup Poll (red, right scale). Source: U.Michigan via FRED, Cummings-Tedeschi, Conference Board, Gallup.